08000 93 00 94
Call us to discuss your claim
08000 93 00 94 Enquire Now

Supreme Court ruling holds MOD to account for soldiers killed in Iraq

June 24, 2013 at 8:41 AM
A landmark judgement handed down by the Supreme Court on 19th June 2013 has paved the way for families of soldiers killed in Iraq and Afghanistan to pursue claims against the Ministry of Defence.
Legal action was brought by relatives of several soldiers tragically killed whilst travelling inside Challenger Tank and Snatch Land Rover military vehicles between 2003 and 2007 in the Iraq conflict.
In its judgement, the Supreme Court ruled that damages claims could be brought in negligence as well as under human rights legislation. 
3 Para in combat in Helmand Province Afghanistan, photo via Open Government Licence v1.0
The MoD had argued that as the soldiers had left their British bases, they were not covered by relevant legislation and therefore the specific obligations imposed within Article two of the European Convention on Human Rights (which imposes a duty on authorities to protect the right to life) were not applicable.
In relation to the allegations of negligence, the MoD's position was that it was not 'fair, just or reasonable' to impose a duty of care when soldiers were on a battlefield.
The court, in rejecting both these assertions held that the soldiers remained within the UK's legal jurisdiction whilst on the battlefield and that the Ministry of Defence did owe a duty of care towards them.
The finding means that claims may be brought where soldiers are deemed to have been sent to war with inadequate or ineffective equipment for instance.
More specifically there have been at least 37 fatalities amongst the armed forces in Iraq and Afghanistan related to the use of the lightly armoured Snatch Land Rover earning it an unenviable nickname amongst soldiers of the 'mobile coffin'.
As the lead representative of the Claimants in the case, Shubhaa Srinivasan commented: 'The highest court in the land has now ruled the MoD, as employer, must accept that it owes a duty of care to properly equip service personnel who go to war'.
Given the outcome of the court hearing, there may be a considerable number of service personnel and families with a potential right of action following death or personal injury.
It is important that they obtain professional legal advice as soon as possible so as to ascertain whether a claim may be pursued, and to ensure that the right to make a claim is not lost through passage of time or other factor.

About the author

Lee FosterLee Foster is a Solicitor and former head of core practice at Spencers Solicitors. A member of the Law Society PI panel as well as being an APIL accredited personal injury specialist, Lee has over twelve year's extensive experience in personal injury law.


Posted in: Articles


© 2017 Spencers Solicitors Limited trading as Spencers Solicitors. Registered in England and Wales No. 06059110. Authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (No. 00466097). This website uses cookies to store information on your device, please read our privacy policy for further details and on how to opt out. Sitemap.